RohantheBarbarian's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Madness Devotion]

Ah yes, another Madness from Krinkies...

Dude, seriously, it isn't funny. Regardless of how you are trashing Krinkels good name, I will review this fairly on the merits of the flash.

Graphics - 8/10 - The animation was very good indeed. To be honest, it was excellent. The characters and backgrounds were all very well drawn.

Content -5/10 - Wasn't much to it. All it consisted of was a speech, with different things happening during it. Could do better

Sound - 1/10 - The voice quality was horrendous, couldn't understand a single word of it. Seriously, invest in a better microphone or something.

Overall - 5/10 - You are ruining (or at least trying to) the reputation of one of NG's most loved artists. I know you probably don't give a damn what I say, but for what it's worth, I think it is a pity. In terms of animation, you have a lot of raw talent, just a shame you are wasting it like this.

Karples responds:

I don't have any intentions of ruining anyone's reputation. :(

[The Battle Field]

Em...

Well it made me chuckle, but other than that it wasn't great.

Graphics - 5/10 - The animation was rather choppy, the effects were a bit unrealistic. However on the other hand the colour usage was fairly decent.

Content - 7/10 - ...Well it certainly was random, so it delivered in that regard. It wasn't hilarious, but as I already said I did chuckle a bit.

Sound - 3/10 - The music was repetitive and I could barely make out the voices.

Overall - 5/10 - The animation was ok, the content was good, but the sound was very poor indeed.

[Intruder Returns]

Un-be-lieveable

This is one of the best flashes I've ever seen on Ng, I am seriously amazed.

Graphics - 10/10 - Flawless. Nothing much else to say. Simply flawless. The detail, the smoothness, everything visual was just a feast for the senses. This is in a different league to 95% (if not more) of the flashes on NG.

Content - 9/10 - An action-packed gunfight featuring all manner of weapons, with swathes of "baddies" being cut down? It's the flash equivalent of every action-lover's wet dream!

Sound - 10/10 - Sound effects were realistic, well implemented into the flash, and were overall just spectacular.

Overall - 10/10 - This is one of the few flashes on NG that would make even the most ardent animation hater fall in love with it. Congratulations on producing one of the greatest movies to ever grace Newgrounds.

[Dos and Donts of Chivalry]

Unbelievable

...I'm lost for words. This deserves a much higher score than it has.

Graphics - 9/10 - The characters and backgrounds were very well drawn and were quite colourful. The only flaw I can find is that some of the animation of subtle movements (hands moving, flag fluttering) was a bit choppy. Otherwise, flawless.

Content - 10/10 - This has honestly made my day; I'm still smiling as I write this. The concept was fairly original and the flash was well laid out with the alternating Do's and Don'ts. Best of all was the humour, which was edgy as well as downright hilarious.

Sound - 10/10 - This is some of the best usage of sound that I've ever seen in a flash. The variety of music was excellent (I particularly enjoyed the music from Ocarina of Time in the credits). The voice acting was flawless also.

Overall - 10/10 - This in my opinion is better than many of the flashes on the Top 50, and it is a pity that more people may not see this as it is among the best things that I have seen on NewGrounds. Fantastic work!

[BLACK trailer 2]

Very good

I'm not a fan of the game, but this was a good flash.

Graphics - 7/10 - The guns were fantastically designed, I was very impressed by this. While I'm not a fan of stickmen, they were used quite well. The animation was very smooth also. The backgrounds were a bit basic for my liking however.

Content - 8/10 - Well to be honest a flash based on a first-person shooter was only going to involve one thing: gunfire. It was interesting enough to prevent it becoming repetitive, and you kept it short enough also. If it was any longer it would have gotten boring.

Sound - 9/10 - The sound won me over completely. The music, while not to my taste, didn't seem out of place. The sound effects (gunshots etc.) were implemented fabulously. Well done on this.

Overall - 8/10 - This far surpassed my expectations. Great job!

[Hay Wars]

Brilliant stuff guys!

I'm a SW nut, so I had high hopes, and man did you guys deliver!

Graphics - 10/10 - I really enjoyed the blend of the Flash messages with the real-life video (albeit with special effects). The blasters shots looked the part, very well done!

Content - 10/10 - The content was so preposterous that it was hilarious! At first I was thinking, "Ok, they're shooting at one another over the haystack, why not?" and was less than impressed. But on watching it a second time I cracked up over the sheer silliness of it. Oh, and way to cap the cameraman at the end!

Sound - 9/10 - I loved the sound effects, they were excellent. The voice quality was a little scratchy though (which is what you lost the point for).

Overall - 9.667/10 - Apart from the voice quality, this submission surpassed all my expectations for a filmed Star Wars parody (let's face it, there are some terrible ones)

Since the overall score is a decimal, I'm rounding it to the nearest whole number, giving you a score of 10. Great job, keep it up!

Fro responds:

What a great review! Thank you for all your kind words. The video and voice quality was bad because of the camera being used. Next time, if there is a next time, we may add the voices by over dubbing them. Thanks for the review.

[The Life of a Chair]

Wonderful

But as has been stated byyour own admission, it is a bit short. It has potential though, maybe consider an extended version, and develop the idea a bit more. Other than that, nicely done.

[flash attack]

Good effort...

...but too similar to Animator vs. Animation for my liking. Maybe make a longer version, and change it a bit more so it does not come off as a poor clone.

rutger438 responds:

oké ty

[The Lucifer Effect.]

Good effort

As you've said, it is a tad short. With a bit of work, this could be very chilling, especially with that music in the background. One thing, when he morphs into the devil, he looks a bit like Venom from Spiderman. Or maybe I'm just crazy ;-)

Ogiyose responds:

yeah now that i think abt it, he does doesn't he?

[Mastermind 3]

LMFAO!!!

Hilarious. Funniest thing I've watched in ages.

BALLS!!!